Performance Pay
Executive Summary of Plan for Teachers
An
Overview of the Douglas County Performance Pay Plan
The
Douglas County performance pay plan for teachers can be considered
as a plan with two major parts. The first part is comprised of the
basic salary structure for all teachers in the district. The second,
and completely distinct from the first, is a series of bonus
incentive components that teachers may participate in voluntarily.
Teachers who choose to participate in one or all of the incentive
components can augment their salary, but under no circumstances do
they risk losing base salary.
Base Salary
Determination
The first part establishes a
teacher's base salary by using a compound interest formula that
factors in both a teacher's number of successful evaluation credits
(what in a salary schedule is termed a longevity step) and the level
of education a teacher has attained. Each factor represents a
percentage value of the base salary. Multiplying these two factors
against the base determines the actual salary a teacher receives.
While this might appear to be a
salary schedule by another name, unlike a conventional single-cell
schedule, under the performance pay plan a teacher does not
automatically receive an increase based on length of service.
Teachers must receive a satisfactory evaluation of their performance
to be eligible for such an increase. Thus, the base salary
distinguishes between "proficient" and
"unsatisfactory" teacher performance. Teachers who receive
an unsatisfactory rating are not eligible to receive an evaluation
credit, a negotiated cost-of-living adjustment, for the coming year.
In essence, their salary is frozen for one year. Moreover,
unsatisfactory performance ratings also preclude the teacher's
participation in any of the bonus incentive components of the plan
Bonus Incentive
Components
The second part of the Douglas County
performance pay plan is composed of a series of incentive bonus
components. All of these components, there are six, are designed to
encourage and reward aspects of teacher performance that were not
traditionally rewarded under the single-cell salary schedule or an
additional activities schedule. Bonus incentive awards are
completely separate from a teacher's base salary and are made as
one-time payments, though eligible teachers may participate each
year.
Group Incentive
Program
The first bonus incentive component
of the pay plan is the group incentive program. This component is
designed to encourage cooperative efforts within schools, or groups
of teachers, to work on common goals that directly impact student
performance. Plans are developed within schools by planning
committees that work with the school's entire staff. Teachers draft
a plan, collect signatures of support from other faculty members,
the building administrator and the building Accountability
Committee. All of this is done prior to submitting the school's
proposal to the Group Incentive Board (GIB), the governing body of
the Group Incentive Plan component. This body reviews the proposed
plan, can recommend revisions, and grants final approval for the
school to move ahead. At the end of the school year, a participating
group compiles a final report detailing the execution of the plan
and evidence of the impact on students. Additionally, reflections of
the overall plan and recommendations for the future are submitted
to GIB. The GIB then makes the determination whether the plan's
goals were met and a bonus should be awarded.
In 2000, the GIB has focused on
aligning a school's improvement plan with its group incentive
proposals. The current thinking is that schools who are able to
enlist 75 percent of their teachers to participate in the group
incentive plan would also be able to use it as their school
improvement plan.
Outstanding Teacher
An another bonus incentive component,
and perhaps most controversial, is the Outstanding Teacher Program.
This component of the plan rewards teachers who have demonstrated
individual outstanding performance. The Outstanding Teacher programs
are currently a bonus of $1250. Today, teachers in Douglas County
can take advantage of four different outstanding programs. The
reason Douglas County has four different programs is due to the fact
that teachers who were successful on Type A a number of times asked
for more and challenging ways to demonstrate their performance.
Type A,
the original outstanding teacher program, uses criterion established
by the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards and
modified by the Outstanding Teacher Committee. To receive the bonus,
teachers notify their building administrator of their intent to
participate, collect six artifacts during the school year supporting
their outstanding performance, compile a portfolio that includes
relevant career and teaching assignment information. Teachers must
also include their educational philosophy and information generated
by peer and client (parents/student) surveys. The portfolio is
submitted to the building administrator at the beginning of May who
then reviews the documentation and makes the decision whether or not
to award the teacher the designation of "Outstanding
Teacher" and the $1250 bonus.
Type B
is a portfolio based on standards-based education. Teachers compile
a "body of evidence" showing their efforts in using
Douglas County's "configuration map" to develop a
standards-based classroom. The configuration map is a rubric that
defines standards-based educational practices on a variety of
domains. Teachers "measure" themselves against the rubric
and submit their portfolios.
Type C
is for teachers who are pursuing National Board Certification. To
limit the amount of paperwork, teachers can submit a copy of their
National Board portfolio with some minor modification.
New for the year 2000, Type
D is based purely on actions resulting in student growth.
Teachers submit proposals directly related to student growth and
measure their success. Teachers will receive the designation based
on their ability to demonstrate "outstanding" student
growth within their unique assignment.
An appeals process was also developed
for teachers who are denied the designation of "Outstanding
Teacher." The appeals board is composed of nine members, five
teachers appointed by the DCFT and four administrators appointed by
the district, and has the authority to review the appeal and
recommend to the superintendent of schools that the decision by the
building administrator be upheld or overturned. The final decision
rests with the superintendent
Skills Blocks
The performance pay plan also
includes a "Skill Block" component designed to provide
incentives for teachers to obtain skills identified by the district
as central to fulfillment of its mission. Skill blocks are offered
at after-school sessions and carry graduated values ranging from
$250 to $500. To receive the skill block bonus teachers must not
only attend training sessions but must also demonstrate mastery of
the skill through an authentic assessment administered at the
conclusion of the training program. In other words, the teacher must
integrate the skill with his or her daily instruction.
Douglas County currently offers nine
skill blocks for teachers and is developing two more. Over time,
skill blocks will be phased out and others added.
Master Teacher
One bonus incentive component that
was incorporated into the plan but was not available until the 2000
school year is "Master Teacher." This component was
intended to address the Colorado Master Teacher License as mandated
by the 1991 Educator Licensing Act. However, those requirements are
still not available and the decision was made to develop criteria
unique to Douglas County. A master teacher must show outstanding
student growth similar to Type D outstanding teacher and possess a
National Board Certification or two years of "outstanding
teacher." Additionally, applicants must show leadership in
their teaching field. Once a teacher receives the master teacher
designation, he or she will be eligible to assume a variety
mentoring roles within Douglas County. The Master Teacher award is
for five years and is currently worth $2,500 each year.
Responsibility Pay
The final bonus incentive component
addresses the issue of additional responsibilities undertaken by
teachers for which they historically have received no additional
compensation. Responsibility pay is broken into to divisions:
district and site based responsibility pay.
District
Responsibility Pay
District responsibility, funded at a
level of approximately $25 per teacher FTE per year, is awarded to
teachers who take on responsibilities at the district level. This
includes such things as membership on the district's Teacher
Evaluation Committee and the Twenty-first Century Partnership, a
committee that considers and approves waivers to board policy and
contract provisions. All of the committees that direct and modify
the performance pay plan are paid by district responsibility.
Site-based
Responsibility Pay
Site based responsibility pay, based
on a per student formula, is distributed at the individual school
level to teachers based on criteria and in award amounts determined
by the school staff. Teachers in every building either elect
representatives or use the entire staff to decide what
responsibilities will be paid and in what amounts. This program is
entirely site-based and there is very little guidance from Central
Office or the DCFT. Schools make their decisions and submit pay
vouchers to the payroll department. |